« Georgia court may have given sex predator custody of child victimsThe 'Silent Scandal' of Courts Putting Children With Their Abusers »

Protecting Abused Children from the Court System

July 10th, 2014

By MCMoewe

U.S. judges routinely force abused children to live with their abusers.

But after nearly a decade of trying, I have given up on the mainstream media doing any significant investigations into this ongoing human rights atrocity. My name is M.C. Moewe. I have worked at several newspapers but my last full-time job was in 2008 as the investigative reporter for the Daytona Beach News-Journal.

My first day on the job, an editor handed me a stack of files asking me to look into a family court custody case. I was surprised, because as anyone who has worked in a newsroom can tell you, there are frequent calls from distraught parents alleging that the other parent is doing something horrible to their child and no one will help.

When that happens, a young reporter listens intently to the caller and then rushes over to their editor, who promptly explains to the newbie that this is a he-said/she-said case simply too difficult to write about. A seasoned reporter listens for as long as they have to, then hangs up without even bothering to tell their editor.

But I had been assigned such a case.

My first job after college was as a crime reporter for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Back then, I had noted that violence inside a family home was hard to write about. I led a team of reporters who investigated how domestic violence was handled by authorities in Fort Worth.

I had to sell my editors on that series. But I was lucky, because Joan Krauter and Lois Norder were incredible editors. I wouldn't realize how rare that was until later in life. The series won several awards and city policies were changed.

So when I got this assignment in Daytona, I felt it was right up my alley. I narrowed in on the custody evaluator in the case. Judges in family court across the U.S. use outside custody evaluators who have enormous power in deciding who gets custody of a child. According to the evaluator, the child's cries of sexual abuse were not credible because the child had a mental disorder.

Other health experts I interviewed were aghast at that theory. I found no evidence that the child had a mental disorder. Even if the child did, other experts told me that children with mental problems are even more likely to suffer abuse because they are more vulnerable to predators. One issue had nothing to do with the other.

I started looking at other cases involving this evaluator. I soon found two other family court cases where the same custody evaluator declared abuse allegations were not credible.

All three of the parents who feared their children were being abused lost custody. One never saw her daughter again -– no visitations, nothing. In the two other cases, for nearly a decade now, both parents remain on supervised visitations, seeing their children for only a few hours each month.

Ironically, had these parents been convicted of a crime, the path to being reunited with their children would be more clear. In criminal courts, parent-child relationships are ended only as a last resort and supervised visitation is accompanied by a written case plan that includes specific steps to reunification.

Family court has no such requirements.

After more than a year of investigating I produced a well-documented story, but, before the story was published, I was laid off along with 100 other employees. It was a double blow for me. Finishing an investigative project is a long and painful process. In the end, if you don't believe in your facts, then you haven't done your job.

My facts indicated that children's reports of abuse were not being handled properly and, very possibly, the children were being court ordered to live with their abusers.

It's a belief that keeps you up at night.

I sent out lots of pitches to other publications. Finally in 2011, the Florida Center for Investigative Reporting agreed to run the story. For several months I updated and dug deeper. But ultimately, FCIR didn't run the story, saying it was the custody evaluator's opinion against the parents.

I understand this is a hard topic to write about. (For that version, I did a rare thing and changed the names of all the family members I was writing about, leaving only the court officials' names real.) No one in the story has been convicted of a crime. If someone does file suit, it goes into the very court system you are writing about and is decided by the same judges who rule that system.

But how, then, can a reporter ever shine a light on this dark area of family court?

My FCIR editor was apologetic and offered to pay for the article anyway. Instead, I asked to be assigned a story that they would run so I could try to shake the disappointment off and get my career back on track.

I wrote a story about leaking petroleum tanks. It did not help me sleep at night.

Meanwhile, I kept getting calls from distraught parents. Now I know around 30 parents who have lost contact with their children after voicing fears in family court that they were being abused.

I had long thought of journalism as my calling. I couldn't imagine doing any other job. But like a cop who can't get past an unsolved case, I found moving on to another story difficult. If I couldn't shine a light on a problem as bad as this one, then journalism just didn't fit with me anymore.

So I decided to come here and write what I normally call thumbsuckers –- stories that explain how a system is broken –- about our family court system.

In my next installment, I will tell you about custody evaluators and their role in the system. I'll introduce you to Stuart Greenberg, a pioneer in the court custody evaluator field who committed suicide after being arrested for secretly filming people in his office bathroom.

To this day, as I collect documents from these cases, often the custody evaluation forms that the parents fill out have tiny script at the bottom that reads "Copyright 1984-97 Stuart A. Greenberg, all rights reserved."

M.C. Moewe is a former criminal justice and investigative reporter for several U.S. newspapers with a B.A. in journalism from the University of North Texas. Email m AT moewe.com or use this link.

No feedback yet

Voices

Voices

  • By Tracy Turner Behind the wholesome facade of your local grocery store lies a cocktail of banned chemicals, deceptive labels, and global food fraud. Safeway. Albertsons. Vons. Trader Joe's. Aldi. These household names conjure an image of bustling…
  • Bilderberg Meeting Attendees (1954–Present): Inside the Secretive Annual Gathering of World Leaders, CEOs, and Influencers Shaping Global Policy and Economic Strategy. Chapter One: The Lords of War and Waste By Ned Lud It begins not with a bang but with…
  • Ned Lud dedicates this to Mark Aurelius Netanyahu: The Prime Minister of Permanent Emergency The Godless Horseman: War Eternal, Peace Never He doesn’t ride in on a white horse—he arrives in Merkava armor, draped in Holocaust memory and wrapped in the…
  • by Janet Campbell Image via Freepik Children on the margins rarely have the luxury of being heard. Their needs are either diluted in policy debates or romanticized in feel-good campaigns that vanish as quickly as they arrive. But improving the lives of…
  • By David Swanson Late last century I figured out that I needed to work on a job dedicated to making the world a better place. I know not everyone can find such a job if they try. I appreciate all the other useful jobs that millions of people do — if not…
  • By Mark Aurelius One can feel the anger. One can feel the rage and disgust. It is a resentment severe but it is far from being some kind of blind hatred. Who could have thought Trump’s White House and Cabinet picks would be this fr..king frustrating,…
  • Robert David I. The New American Panopticon In 1971, Daniel Ellsberg leaked the Pentagon Papers, exposing the government’s lies about the Vietnam War. Today, a different kind of betrayal unfolds—not through war, but through data, algorithms, and…
  • Tracy Turner In recent years, Trader Joe's and Aldi have emerged as successful grocery store chains, with their private-label products that usually bear organic labels. But behind such appealing labels lies a disturbing reality: a significant proportion…
  • By Chris Spencer I. The New Alchemists: Turning Paranoia into Profit In the digital crucible of the 21st century, a strange alchemy has emerged: paranoia transmutes into profit, and the specter of chaos becomes a business model. Surveillance—once the…
  • By David Swanson, World BEYOND War Approaching 50 years since the end of the American War, as the Vietnamese call it, and something over 70 years since the start of it, depending when you start the clock, truth and reconciliation remain incomplete. I…
April 2025
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30      

  XML Feeds

CMS + user community
FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted articles and information about environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. This news and information is displayed without profit for educational purposes, in accordance with, Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Thepeoplesvoice.org is a non-advocacy internet web site, edited by non-affiliated U.S. citizens. editor
ozlu Sozler GereksizGercek Hava Durumu Firma Rehberi Hava Durumu Firma Rehberi E-okul Veli Firma Rehberi